Houndoc said:
Not looking for a daily driver. The long term idea is replace the mini-van with a Suburban for family trips, horse hauling etc (thus the other big rig thread I started a month or two back). Currently my DD and off-road is 03 Montero Sport. Once I have a good trail rig, then the Monty Sport can be replaced with something with better milage since I commute 85 mile/day round trip.
The boat we currently use is a 22'. (And yes boating in October can be cold, but it is a fun way to get into places most people don't bother to hunt. The worst part is having to "winterize" it when we pull out each night on a cold year. Wish it was an outboard).
With the Blazer/Bronco/Ram Charger crowd, the only issue I can really see that can limit them is the width. Wheel base and turn is still relatively small. When I can get a vehicle that does not have to be my daily driver, then getting it equiped for Constrictor and similar trails is the plan.
So, with a goal of towing about 6k pound, 35" tires, locker and relatively cheap......the winner is???
I have also thought Durango (old style) but don't know how easy they are made trail worthy. 5.7l and a perfect size.
I think you'd be surprised at the capability of any of the full-size rigs mentioned. They're relatively cheap, reliable as a brick and easy to fix if they do give you trouble (usually with baling wire, zip-ties and/or duct tape until you can get a permanent repair). They can tow relatively well (6,000 lbs is about the limit I'd go with any of the mentioned due to the light half ton classification) for their size.
This particular RamCharger pictured usually towed an XJ to Moab, ran trails with us and then towed an XJ home. It wasn't optimal for towing, but it did fine.
I was SHOCKED at the capability of my '89 Sub at the Summer U4WDA event. I crawled through the bulk of the rock garden in Mineral Basin with BFG AT racing slicks (worn out AT/KOs) and open diffs. If I got serious with the Sub., I'd definitely want a D60 front, just for the sheer weight of the thing (6000 lbs according to Flying J's scale). A '87-91 Sub/Blazer is a GREAT value and comes with TBI fuel injection which makes them pretty driveable at any angle and is extremely reliable. The going price for a NICE specimen is on the order of $3000-5000. They just go down in price from there.
I'd be glad to sell you my V2500 Sub (I've got a pickup I need to buy) or there's another Blazer I noticed in the 'For Sale' section today. Just an FYI on mileage. On a trip to Toelle to play golf a month or so ago, I kept my RPM at 2500 and my speed at about 68-69 mph, got 14.4 mpg with 35" tires and 4.10 gears. How I normally drive, I get about 12 mpg, but IMHO that ain't too bad for a vehicle that can tow my junk OK, wheel a little and is reliable enough for daily driver status.
Blazer
http://www.rockymountainextreme.com/showthread.php?t=21180
towing b!tch Suburban (door is not nearly in as bad of shape, nowadays)--GM says it can tow up to 9,800 lbs (which seems a little high, but whatever). I towed a 7500 lb trailer from Woods Cross to 4th North area in Salt Lake and it did pretty decent once you got the thing moving.
http://www.rockymountainextreme.com/showthread.php?t=25580