Having seen a melted alum pie iron personally I will say this...
If I were to be cooking up a scrumptious, beautiful--godsend of a food such as the bacon wrapped mushrooms pictured earlier and my pie iron happened to melt into a puddle in the process I... well... I just don't know if I could handle it mentally :-\
There are 3 things in life you should never do:
1. Don't tug on Superman's cape
2. Don't overheat a 6.2L diesel engine
3. NEVER waste a perfectly good strip of bacon.
For me the alum pie irons are just not worth the risk :-\
Well, luckily some of us have the sense not to try to cook on a fire that is hotter than 1,220* . Having made bacon more than once in my life, I can say with a reasonably degree of certainty that temperatures around that range are not ideal bacon-cooking temps--alume or iron.
Having seen a broken cast iron pie maker, I would say it would be just as awful to have you set down you heavy, old-fashioned, and technologically outdated cooking apparatus on a rock and have it split open thus sending your greasy, bacony, goodness all over the fire.
For me, iron just isn't worth the risk.
Last edited: