Public vs charter vs private depends a lot on test scores and neighborhood kids. My 9 year old was accepted into an amazing charter school that would’ve taken him from 1st to 9th but we researched the public school and we were pleasantly surprised by test scores and opinions from neighbors/friends. We ultimately decided on that path. Neighborhood kids matter because if your child has friends in the neighborhood that will benefit them socially.
This times 1000!
My 13 yr old has been in private catholic school since pre-k, due to her mother wanting it even though neither of us are catholic (I think some sort of "bragging rights" for her or something)
. While I like her education she is getting and feel that it has benefitted her, especially being in a split household/neighborhood scenario, it just hasn't helped as much with the social stuff as much as I had hoped.
Separated parents/neighborhoods may be more to blame...but not having kids around in your neighborhood that you are friends with is a huge problem I think. Granted, going to some form of Sunday service should help that (neither me and my wife, nor my daughter's mother do) but if that is the only exposure to neighborhood kids I saw growing up how they can be ostracized with the neighborhood "group"
I wish my daughter were in public school...to me the expense isn't quite justifying the benefits and her mother and I live close enough to each other that either neighborhood has kids in the same middle school.
Just a thought. I do think pre-k is worth it...not just for the kids but also for the parents getting a little free time as you mentioned.