Ah ok, thought I read ARB for some reason, Yeah I don't see how bumper would cause it either?
Hell I busted half my body mounts through the tub on my YJ, Still not sure how the hell it happened.
After a bit of reading they are thinking that the bumper is violently hitting the body when flexing, not only is it possible, but its likely. ARB recommends a 25mm (1" gap) when installing their bumpers, I'm not sure about the others. I'd be willing to be quite a few of these guys had theirs right close to the body as it "looks better". Whereas the stock bumper would flex if it contacted the body, the ARB (and other heavy duty winchbars) won't, so the body has to flex somewhere... cracks are the end result. I've even seen guys dremel out their mounting holes so they can mount the bumper up tighter than the ARB mounts will allow... now you know why you shouldn't.
Funny thing is I was just arguing with an RME'er about this on his ARB bumper equipped 07' Tacoma... I told him it would crease his fender, I didn't think it could crack it
Mabey he will listen now