rckcrlr said:
...The reason you can find them is the Bronco and explorer guys replace them with something better....
JMHO
Marc
The reason you find them so plentiful (at least in the case of finding a replacement for a TJ/YJ) is that they're from wrecked Explorers, not people upgrading. Here are some reasons why they're so popular:
1-easy to find in junkyards
2-they cost around $300 (I found mine $475 brand new shipped to my house)
3-1.31" 31-spline axle shafts (Explorer version)
--stock 8.8" shaft torque load = 5100 lbs
--stock D44 shaft torque load = 3400 lbs
--stock 30-spline D60 = 5600 lbs
4-disk brakes (Explorer, '95 and newer)
5-very close to stock TJ/YJ width (Explorer)
6-same bolt pattern as TJ/YJ
7-almost a bolt-on for YJs (Explorer)
8-can be found with popular jeep gear ratios, ie 3.55, 3.73 and 4.10
9-lots of locker options
10-ring and pinion is bigger than D44
Drawbacks include:
1-thin-walled tubes
2-c-clip (try breaking an axle shaft first)
3-large pumpkin
4-thin diff cover
An 8.8" will
easily handle 35's, even rock crawling. I wouldn't hesitate to put 37's on an 8.8", but if I planned to wail on it, I'd go with alloy shafts. The only reason I'd go with a 9" over an 8.8 (if both were priced the same and available) is because of the bigger bearings and the 35-spline option.
Devin
EDIT: a thread comparing a D44 and a Ford 8.8" from jeepsunlimited.com -
http://www.jeepsunlimited.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=528623&highlight=8.8+comparison