My dad had an 04? Escape. Drove it 175,000 miles with only oil, gas, 1 set of front brakes and tires. I know you want better fuel mileage but just consider how much more you will have to pay for a Toyota badge? Every $1000 more you pay for the vehicle, you could be putting that towards paying for the fuel. To be fair, there isnt any model/manufacturer that can run 200K to 300K with no issues in 75% of the production run. There are always those cherries that get well cared for and last forever but 300K with no issues is a tall order unless they are all highway miles.