Found this thread again. Figured I'd bring it back because I'm bored at work and its funny now because now I have almost every stove I asked about in my original post. Figured I'd review them for other's reference.
Coleman suitcase 2 burner - Awesome stoves (the older they are the awesomer they are), super reliable, cake to rebuild, should never fail unless you do something stupid. They're just really klunky to have in a bumpy landcruiser. They do burn ultra hot compared to most other stoves and having two burners is nice, but I usually just end up using two single burners.
Coleman 502 - Possibly my favorite stove. Its like a brick, but its by far the easiest to light, prime, and control the flame on. Super reliable, stable, and ok in wind. Can simmer well. Not very high heat output compared to the others.
Coleman Peak 1 (similar to the exponent) - Almost the same as the 502 but smaller, lighter, and much more powerful. Harder and more dangerous to light and control, but still rock solid and better in wind.
Svea 123 and Hunter 8R
Same stove just a different case and tank. Doesn't pump so its a little trickier to prime, but they are so small and reliable (and classic
)
I don't have either of these, but if anyone has one that they want to get rid of, let me know cause I want both of them badly.
Optimus Hiker Plus
Another favorite, because it looks great and its so convenient in it's little case. Its like a mini coleman suitcase. It burns very hot and uses any fossil fuel (I havent tried anything other than white gas). It also is sometimes very hard to light, sometimes hard to prime, not too great in the wind, and gets sooty if you don't prime it well. It supposedly has a magnetic cleaning needle, but it doesn't work very well. A better option would be the
Optimus Hiker (aka Optimus 111T) which is the same thing but its quieter, easier to light, prime, use in the wind, clean, and simmer. I have one but I haven't used it much because its in pieces getting restored. Used ones are mucho $$$ (over $100, easy).
I also have some 1950s Coleman 500 single burner stoves that are gigantic versions of the 502 (or single versions of the 2 burner). They burn really hot but take longer to prime and aren't as good in the wind. They simmer well and look cool cause they are sixty years old.
Yes I'm a stove nerd now. :greg:
And I still hate on propane.