So I've had success with both the glue traps and 5gal bucket trap over the last few weeks. I used the bucked trap (with pop can on a wire/water in bottom) in the garage and caught a bunch.
Right now both traps have peanut butter smeared on them and no signs of disturbance so I think I might be mouse free for awhile Thanks again everyone.
Saw a little bastard in the garage tonight. Had the big door open for about an hour after work, I stepped out into the garage and saw him hurry away. Went and bought just the traditional wood snap-traps and some mouse bait that claims to "work better than cheese or peanut butter ". The hunt is on.