I have a MH 3 man too, might even be the same one, weighs about the same 8 lbs. My cot just fits in it, and I can at least sit up on my cot to pull on my pants and boots. When using it for two, usually me and my Son, we have to sleep on pads on the ground. I use it in places where I might not be able to get a tent stake in good and free standing might be a big asset. Slick rock areas, for instance. This is it at the Maze Overlook a couple months ago.
I also use it when I'm being cargo weight conscious, like when I did the Rubicon trail with my Son a few years back.
I can attest that it's bomber, as far as wind and wet go. The night the picture below was taken, was one of the top five most ferocious storms I have ever been in. The tent shrugged it off. The Coleman tents in our group utterly failed. Letting in tons of wind driven rain, before just collapsing. The people in them had really miserable nights. The story I am told, is that at one point during a very brief lull in the storm, my buddy was holding his collapsed Coleman up from the inside where he and his girlfriend were soaked and cold and miserable. So, wind and hail let up for just few seconds, and they said they could hear me snoring, in my Mountain Hardware. Said of all the times they have wanted to kill me, that was the strongest urge to kill
.
I've only had a Springbar fail once. In one of the other top five most ferocious storms of my life. Upright pole snapped in really high wind at Flaming Gorge. Hi Lift handle to the rescue
. Can't know, but suspect that Mountain Hardware tent would not have had an issue in the same situation. But, that is once, in my whole life, and I have spent an awful lot of nights in Springbars in my life. And, not for nothing, I had to go out and get wet to fix it, but it didn't take very long and then I was able to go back in my Springbar where nothing had really gotten very wet inside and fire up the heater and get warm and dry and go back to sleep. And, also not for nothing, but the remaining three, top five ferocious storms, were all in a Springbar without issue. So, I'm inclined to call it even, as far as storm worthy goes, for any practical purposes.
The MH is a lot noisier in wind and rain though, a LOT noisier. And the MH takes quite a bit longer to setup and take down, for me at least.
Most of my camping is in the winter. So being able to have a heater in the Springbar is a big deal. So at times is being able to bring my stove and a table and a chair inside to cook and eat in foul weather. Due to my back, my fused neck, my general feebleness and lack of flexibility, it really is awful nice for me to be able to stand up in the morning too. I sleep in long johns in cold weather, then take them off and change into my day layers in the morning. Being able to fire up a heater, then stand up, is a luxury I am appreciative of. I do enough backpacking in really small tents, I know what getting dressed laying down like a hobo is all about and I really don't care for it. It's just a lot more pleasant for me in the Springbar. And of course it fits two cots.
For me, the Springbar is just easier. Sets up and takes down just too much faster and easier - for me.
I actually just finished packing the Jeep, leaving for a trip tomorrow. I don't expect to even use a tent, weather should be good enough to just sleep on my cot under the stars. But I am taking a tent anyway, just in case. Started to throw the MH in, since it is much smaller and lighter, why pack the bigger Springbar when I don't expect to even use it. But then I thought, "ehhh, the Sprinbar is a lot easier to put up, if I do end up using a tent". And I'm traveling alone, so plenty of cargo space and I'm not trying to save weight on this trip either. So, I put the Springbar in the Jeep.
It's all personal preference. With a bit of golf bag approach thrown in. I have six tents that I actually use. Made by Springbar, Mountain Hardware, Big Agnes and Six Moon Design. I think they are all awesome tents. They each fill a niche and are "just right" for certain situations. But my smaller Springbar does get used more than all the others put together. "For me", it's usually the "easy button" for most situations.
Few gratuitous Springbar pics just because I am both a pic posting ho and a Springbar ho.
- DAA