Weight is a non-issue. The weight is unspung, so it holds the rig to the ground like water or lead in the tires.
CR
except when you're dealing with physics. A heavier rig needs more friction to climb the same surface. there are plenty of obstacles that a lighter rig will dance up and a heavy rig can't do. running water in your tires does add unsprung weight--which in many situations can be a benefit--but it also changes the contact patch of the tire, how it reacts to the ground (how bouncy it is etc) and other characteristics. It also changes the weight bias of the vehicle--it's common knowledge that front heavy rigs climb much better than rear heavy (and conversly front heavy rigs suck at coming off big drops--to this I can personally attest )
there are also situations where big ass tires help too.
rockwells have there place, but I've only run into 1 buggy in my life that I thought executed them well for our terrain (that green and black one in Price). Other than that, those big, heavy, tall, wide, awkward, heavy balloon tired rigs you see with them aren't exactly nimble nor dialed for the type of terrain we wheel here.
I'm with shane on dimensions--outside tire to outside tire ~74-78" for a trail rig. I don't see any need for a tire bigger than 40" for the terrain we have here.
Just my 2 pesos