Wow....so here is what it could very well be then....Last summer I dropped the gas tank to replace the pump (with a used one). I put it all back together and on my next fill up I found that I didn't get the big nut, that mounts the fuel pump, tight enough and gas leaked out when the tank got full. I found that if I don't put in more gas, and over fill it after the pump stops, then it won't leak. I have never had time to drop the tank again to tighten it up....dumb, I know. It never gave me any issues til now. Looks like I will be dropping it again soon. Time for a Jeep day. And I will probably replace the cat and muffler too.
Cracked hose inside the tank??.....I bet it took a while to find that one. I'm impressed that you did. I never would have thought of that.
Thanks for all the help and suggestions from everyone. Much appreciated!