Sorry, this is a bit lengthy but I've been playing with some theories and spring options over the past several years in order to dial in my Jeep's on and off-road ride characteristics right down to the gnat's ass. I think I am on the right track of finding that balancing act between ride height, road manners, off-road manners and ride quality. I know that each company has suspension systems for the masses but we all have our vehicles either loaded differently or configured in some manner that makes a mass produced kit less than ideal. I also think ride quality, looks and overall off-road ability to many is somewhat subjective. So here's my thoughts on where I'm at with my Jeep JKUR.
After a few off-roading trips this year I have been thinking through a few alterations to my suspension. Back when I first built the Jeep in 2011 I had purchased a BDS 4.5" long-arm suspension system and over the years I have tweaked and modified it to resolve what I think were design flaws and to customize it to my liking. Things such as building my own links to incorporate rubber encapsulated (Clevite) style bushings and Johnny Joints vs. the BDS proprietary bushings that kept failing. Also over the years as my Jeep has gained a few pounds I have played with rear coil springs in order to chase rear ride height as well as overall ride characteristics. I replaced the BDS coils several years ago with some OME ones that rode nice but still didn't give me quite the height I was after so I added a 1" spacer to get me closer. Ride height was better but overall ride was a bit "soggy" feeling.
Next up was I added some 4.5" plus Currie over-landing rear coils. These were recommended by Currie as a direct replacement for their 4.5" suspension springs but for one that is loaded a bit heavier in the rear for over-landing. These were better but still not quite where I wanted to be. I ended up added a 1/2" spacer but again ride height was still a bit lower than I would like in the rear and with a couple people in the rear I was contacting my jounce stops over bumps.
As I have been toying over thoughts over the past six months of playing off-road as well as on pavement I determined that I wanted to try a rear spring that had not only a bit more free length but also a slightly stiffer spring rate. On the last couple of off-roading trips I noticed that when climbing a rather steep ledge or shelf that I could actually feel the weight transfer to the rear as I ascended the climb which I feel was making my Jeep lose traction at the front tires. My thinking is that if I install a rear coil spring with a stiffer spring rate it would benefit two-fold. First, it would give me that little bit of extra lift at ride height, I figured about 3/4" would be about ideal as I don't want the front end lower than the rear. I like that nose high look and feel. Secondly, I think that as I am climbing if the rear didn't compress so easily it would help keep my front end planted and maintain traction with the front tires.
My search for spring rates and free length went on for a few weeks and many phone calls as most companies don't list such specifics. Well after a long discussion with a gentleman at Metalcloak suspensions a couple of weeks ago I opted to give something a try. He thought I should use their 4.5" true dual rate springs but I informed him I haven't had the best luck with anyone's 4.5" springs as they are netting me closer to 3.25"-3.5" of net lift due to the weight. He said he has overlanding Jeeps that use them and they get more height than advertised but I again informed him that I feel mine is a bit heavier than having a tent on my roof and a refrigerator in the rear. I was not doubting his knowledge as he was very knowledgeable and obviously has more experience than I do, I just know my Jeep.
In the end I ordered a set of their 5.5" dual rate springs because I didn't want to use spacers again as I wanted to use all effective coils to accomplish what I was after.
The springs showed up on Friday so Saturday I made quite a few measurements and then swapped out the rear coil springs. I think I am on to something with a cure for pavement driving but I will have to wait until I can get off-road to test the off-pavement manners.
So far here are my results. Starting photos. Jeep with 4.5" Currie over-landing rear coil springs and a beginning measurement of 32-1/8" from bottom of wheel to rolled lip of fender flare. My goal would be in the range of 33" to max. of 33-5/8" at ride height. Also worth noting is that I am not running my hi-lift jack, Yeti cooler, lawn chairs and I have just under 1/4 tank of fuel. This will be the highest ride height I should experience.
After removing my Currie 4.5" over-landing springs you can see the free length difference between the Currie 4.5" coils and the Metalcloak 5.5" coils, much more than merely an inch. Also look at the diameter of the coils and the pitch. The Metalcloak's are about .062" thicker and the pitch is greater resulting in the slightly higher spring rate. The Currie's were 88 lbs/in and the Metalcloak's are 100 lbs./in. spring rate so not much but only slightly stiffer.
New Metalcloaks installed at droop.
New Metalcloaks installed at ride height.
Final measurement at ride height after a test drive to let everything settle is 33-3/8" so a height gain of 1-1/4". A bit more than I wanted but slightly less than my max amount. I had acquired my maximum amount by leveling the Jeep as I do not want the rear higher than the front at any time.
I also checked the angle after my test drive and I am still very slightly nose high with .4 degrees of difference front to rear, rear being ever so slightly lower.
So far I only have about 150 miles on the new rear coils but I can definitely tell a difference on the pavement. It is not harsh by any stretch of the word but it did firm up the rear end. Going over interstate bridge seams and railroad tracks at speed is where I have noticed it the most. The rear end feels much more planted with the road and hardly any undulations from the rear end. I even did some high speed cornering yesterday, well as high speed as you can in a Jeep anyways, and it is much more stable in the corners. We have a rather winding on-ramp to the freeway and upon accelerating aggressively it felt so much more stable and firm that I could push it even harder than really necessary. I really wanted to push it a bit so I could rule out just having a placebo affect with spring swap and so far there is definitely a favorable difference on the pavement. It still floats going down the interstate @ 70 MPH though so my street manners did not suffer and actually improved slightly. Now the real test will be the off-road manners.
Thanks for looking.
Mike