Think of it this way, if you average 7 mpg with that load you're doing just fine. My 2017 cummins wouldn't get any better than 8.5 mpg pulling it, and your fuel AND payment are significantly less.
Just doing some mapping for a Moab trip. With 25 gallons @ 7.5 mpg I’ll NOT make Green River from Woods Cross. (Short about a gallon). However, if I just stop at Wellington on the way there and the way back, I should be ok? I think for a first trip, I’ll fill a 5 gallon (the 5 gallons is at least 25-30 miles in a worst case scenario on a road with a fair amount of gas stations on it) can up just in case I use A LOT going up Spanish Fork canyon (although there is that gas station at Soldier Summit).
Not necessary for the extra fuel can but some insurance in case I pull the canyon at 2-3 mpg (which I think will happen a bit—Thistle will suck out at least a gallon and the pull from the rest area to the summit will drag at least 2-3 gallons?). I can get to Wellington (133 miles)on 25 gallons if I average 5.36 mpg. 4.76 would get me to Helper (119 miles).
On the way back, the pull out of Helper up to the Scofield turn off will suck down some gas but I should be ok after that? Oh, the math
My payment on this truck is great. Insurance is about $75 per month. I don’t expect a lot of repairs. It cost me my G8
but is a good fit (and I’ll buy a car with a $2 key and stupid amounts of torque at some point anyway——GS, fake GTO or SS Chevelle or something fun like that)