Here is a list of vehicles I have looked at so far (maybe more to keep them straight for me than anyone else's benefit), and my impressions (my honest feeling about the vehicle with no disrespect intended should the owner be on here and read this).
Full disclosure, I compare all vehicles to my past experience (good or bad) to vehicles I have owned and driven. Most recently, my heavily modified 2010 JKUR and my 2014 F150. Keep my bias in mind while reading my impressions as I know I am comparing apples and watermelons...
I have also owned 1 Toyota in the past, a 1990 4Runner with the craptastic 3.0. It has taken me 16 years after that experience to seriously consider drinking the Toyota Kool Aide again. After owning an 05 Rubi LJ, and my 2010 JKUR, I really hate Chrysler (fair or not, i have no love left for them)...
The first vehicle I drove while beginning my search was this 2005 LC 100 series with 120k or so miles for $18.5k:
http://www.ksl.com/auto/listing/2679481
The owner is a super cool guy. This thing is a little dirtier inside than i like (typical carpet stains and a detail job would go a long way) but the service record is great and detailed. I wouldn't worry at all about reliability of this rig based on the service record, but I can't justify blowing my whole budget on 1 vehicle and have nothing left to buy the 2nd one, or do any repairs/mods to either. The owner says he has it listed for what the dealer will give him for trade, so good a private buyer that wants it for a deal. This was my first let down with the feel of 4.7 and peppy driving. I shiver at the thought of what this will feel like with a lift, larger tires, and weight of all my crap loaded into it. The plus size is durability and reliability.
After the 100 series, I jumped on KSL to see what else was in the area, and decided to check out a FJ Cruiser. Knowing a couple of people on here with them that have good things to say about the FJ's, and noticing they came in a 6 speed, I found this one and decided to go look at it.
2007 FJ Cruiser with 86k miles for $17k.
http://www.ksl.com/auto/listing/2635736
My first impression was how peppy the vehicle is with the 4.0 and 6 speed. It was fun to drive (after I finally figured out the shift pattern). The interior lighting sucks (it was dark when i drove it), and the side mirrors leave a lot to be desired. This specific vehicle has a strange engine tick, like noisy lifters, but served as a good test vehicle to see if I can envision buying one. I haven't ruled them out, but an FJ is still an option.
Next I drove Ferg's 2000 LX 470, 146k miles for $12k. To be honest, I am still considering this vehicle, even though I hope Ben has good luck and sells it quickly for his sake. He seems to be a great guy!
http://www.ksl.com/auto/listing/2637436
This is a 16 year old vehicle, and has some of the marks to show for it. It does drive nice, and it is evident it has been cared for. I personally would be putting tires on it ASAP (wear from an alignment problem causing uneven wear, and I am not sure 2 of the tires will pass inspection, but I could be wrong) and having an alignment done. This drives nice and feels tight, but has the same "slow motion" feel of the 2005 I drove earlier. If I go the LC route, and this is still available, I will be making an offer on this.
Next I drove this 2003 Lexus GX470. It has 96k miles and they are asking $11.4k.
http://www.ksl.com/auto/listing/2615513?ad_cid=29
This is a rocket ship compared to the LX, but this particular vehicle is a little rough (even with low miles). The hood release latch is broken where it attaches to the grill (not a big deal alone), the interior has been well abused (likely a family vehicle, not indicative of a little old lady that babies their car), the driver’s seat warmer didn't work, the sunroof was frozen shut (I can't say it doesn't work, but it wouldn't open when I test drove it), but the service records show mechanical care has been performed most of its life. This one will need a timing belt and water pump in the coming year or so, but I am still considering this rig. For me to buy it though, they will have to deal a fair amount to close the gaps.
Next, I looked at this 2007 GX470 in Bountiful. 160k miles for roughly $14k
http://www.ksl.com/auto/listing/2623616?ad_cid=11
I started this rig and looked it over, but in talking with the dealer, left without driving it. This appears to be a solid rig, but nothing about it made me want to justify spending the money on it over the 03 listed about that I think I could get a better deal on.
I had my eye on a 1999 4Runner in Bountiful that had 156k miles for $7.8k, and wanted to drive it. When I went to call on the ad, it was gone off KSL, so I can only assume it sold. I was bummed I didn't get to look at it.
Next, I looked at this CJ5, mainly because it is close to my house and has some desirable upgrades. 83 CJ 5 for $8k
http://www.ksl.com/auto/listing/2065948?ad_cid=16
The owner started this up, but I didn't drive it. It was freaking cold outside, and the heater doesn't work. He also would have had to move too many vehicles out of the way to get to drive it, and after discussing some of my concerns, and his price, decided I wasn't serious enough to go through the motions. It fired right up, and seems to be cancer free (body is the best I've seen in a CJ in a long time). I haven't driven a CJ 5 since I sold mine in 2005, and forgot how small they were! I prefer the 7 for that extra inch of leg room in the front seats, but haven't ruled a 5 out completely. I am sure this is worth what he is asking, but it isn't worth that much to me, so my search continued.
Out in West Haven is this little gem (to the right person anyway). 76 CJ7, T18 trans with fuel injected 258, on 33" pizza cutters for $7.8k.
http://www.ksl.com/auto/listing/2150169?ad_cid=12
This has some cancer, but nothing like others i have seen in this vintage. I was pleasantly surprised by the Jeep, and it isn't too far from being a great project for someone, but for the price it isn't for me. I would make too many changes to justify spending that much as a starting place.
While in the area, I stopped to look at this 04 GX 470 with 136k for $11.5k.
http://www.ksl.com/auto/listing/2686283?ad_cid=18
It has been sitting for a few weeks, and struggled a little to fire up, but then seemed to run ok. The owner says he just purchased it in Dec of 15, and the registration supports that. He is selling it now for personal reasons. It was scheduled to have the Timing belt and water pump replaced today (2/5/16). I drove it down the street for a quick ride, and right away felt something not right in the rear end. I pulled into the parking lot of a Winco in the area, and crawled under it with my flashlight to see it was sitting on the rear bump stops. The air suspension was not functioning in the rear. I checked the rest of the rig over, and tried changing the suspension setting to see if it would lift off the bump stop, but had no luck. I returned to the seller’s house and informed him of my findings. He said he will look into repairing this and seems to be a standup guy, but I only talked to him for about 20 min… I have ruled this one out for me (going back to the 03 with fewer miles for roughly the same money), but if fixed, might make a good ride for someone else searching.
I have made some phone calls on other KSL adds, some good, some I’ve ruled out, some are just too far away to get to until I have more free time in daylight.
Long winded post, but a place where I can compile my thoughts on vehicles for later reference.