218 reply's!
Tow rig and daily driver... That's tough and for me it eliminates all the V10's and big block gassers. They just do not provide fuel economy that I can live with. If you only use them to tow it might be worth considering that option, but for me they are out. Most late model small block gassers will pull your Toyota just fine for the most part and give you decent mileage as a daily driver but you will NEVER want to pull two rigs unless you have a very light trailer.
For starters am far from a die hard Ford fan (If Toyota made a truck like this I would have one LOL) and this is only my reasoning and opinion so everyone please take it with a grain of salt. Not trying to pimp my vehicle in any way just sharing some info about it because not too many people are familiar with them
I bought a truck that fit my needs and Ford was the ONLY one to offer the true four door with a mechanically injected diesel and a manual overdrive transmission with a solid front axle. I've been through quite a few trucks trying to find the right one and so far I am extremely happy and very satisfied with the Ford and I have NO desire to buy something newer or different. Here is my reasoning....
7.3 IDI. While its not a powerhouse compared to the new trucks it will still put out plenty of usable power. It is also right up there with the 12valve Cummins for reliability and simplicity. I like the fact that every component on this engine is serviceable and wear items are cheap to replace for the most part. There is no need to have a technician trouble shoot it or to pay big money for dealer only parts either. A new injector pump and injectors cost 1/10th the cost of anything on the electronic diesels and I can change them out myself (if they ever go bad) with basic tools. This motor had a long production run and aside from industrial use it was placed in the most popular light duty pickup sold from 83-94 which is really nice when it comes to sourcing parts.
Manual trans: I'm done with automatics in full size trucks--well I haven't owned an Allison but for the most part I'm done
They can work well but they are expensive to replace when they don't. Buying a used truck means you have no idea what the transmission has been through and that could cost in the long run. I prefer towing with a manual as well as I feel it gives me a lot more control.
Crew cab: Fitting the entire family comfortably was really important to me. I like the space and I feel its better to have it and not need it than need it and not have it. Car seats in the super cabs are a pita and a regular cab truck does me no good whatsoever.
1ton axles. Solid front dana 60 and Sterling rear. I don't have premature balljoint, rod end, pitman or idler problems and I never will. These components are very stout and work well offroad.
Diesel. Better mileage, better power, longer lasting (well depending on which one you go with) and stupid simple/reliable if you go mechanical. For my money it would be 12 valve Cummins or Ford IDI or a 7.3 Powerstroke with a detailed service history. Problem with Fords in the late 80's and 90's is the TTB front end in the F250's (F350's didn't have that later than 85.5) and the auto trans. If you find a older Ford with an auto its not a question of if the trans will go out its a matter of when :-\ Anyway if these interest you price them out in the classifieds. They are really cheap compared to the Dodges (Cummins) and the newer diesel trucks.