Funny you should mention that. I was standing on a door step of a guy I was meeting for the very first time. I introduced myself and we chatted for a bit. Gave him the customary church invite and his response was identical to yours, minus, "craft". I told him a few beer jokes and we had a good laugh. He quickly realized I was a decent guy and not too churchy. He invited me to stop by again when I was around. That was about 4 years ago. I see him and his family in church every week now. We still joke about looking for beer in the church.
Don't jinx yourself.