I tried Eggbeaters, and they made my foot very uncomfortable, felt like I was riding on my tip toes. With the Shimano style, or Times I didn't have that problem. I'm back to wide downhill style platforms now. They work great for what I have been doing the last 4 years, lots of time just riding with my son. Grab the bike and go without having to change my shoes. If I ever do another race (doubtful) I will throw the SPDs back on.